Rookgaard asks for little: don’t take away what worked
Echo raids livened up Rookgaard for a few weeks and were switched off on October 27. The island doesn’t need to become endgame, but it deserves care.
There is a part of the Tibia community that chose, on purpose, never to leave the island. They are the rookstayers: characters without a vocation who level up on Rookgaard, collect rare items, build guilds, organise events and keep alive the island where everyone started. Many have been there for years. It is not a lack of options. It is a way to play.
In October, this group got a gift and lost it within a few weeks.
What happened
With the Echo Raids system, killing certain creatures can trigger a raid with stronger monsters and its own loot. For a few weeks, that also worked on Rookgaard. According to the island’s own players, it was the liveliest period in a long time: people returning to old characters, hunting again, trading the new items.

On October 27, CipSoft switched it off. In that day’s list of fixes, one short line: it is no longer possible to trigger an echo raid when killing a creature on Rookgaard. A week later, on November 3, the same line appeared for Newhaven.

The same day, Tarik Rooker, a level 178 rookstayer on the world Peloria, opened a thread on the proposals board asking for the raids to return to the island. The arguments were simple: the items give no meaningful experience advantage, Rookgaard’s main equipment has no imbuement slots, nobody died because of the raids and, in the end, the items work as collectibles. The thread passed 40 replies, almost all from island players backing the request, Landroan among them, the player in the image above. As of November 16, no official reply.

Read Tarik Rooker’s request and add your support on the official forum
Rookgaard doesn’t need to become endgame
I want to be fair to both sides. Some people in the same thread said the island should remain a memorial of old Tibia, a retro experience, and that new things change its character. That is a legitimate position.
And I agree with half of it. Rookgaard doesn’t need to become endgame. Nobody is asking for a new boss, a new hunting ground or a forge on the island. The charm of Rookgaard is precisely that it is small, limited, with its own rules. Those who stay there know it and like it.
But there is a big difference between not transforming the island and taking away something that was already working without breaking anything. The raids didn’t change the island’s balance. The items they gave mostly ended up on a shelf. What they brought was movement, and movement is exactly what Rookgaard needs most.
The fear that hangs in the air
CipSoft didn’t explain the reason for the change. Without an explanation, the impression is that the concern is something else: that Rookgaard might become too good. Good enough that players spend more time on their rookstayer than on their main, and spend less where the game actually makes money.
If that is it, the concern is overblown. A rookstayer is not a competitor to a main. Many rookstayers have a main. And several island players pointed out in the thread that the raids encouraged the opposite: coming back to play, activating Premium to collect what the raids left behind and getting item trading going. A small treat on the island doesn’t take money out of the game. It might even bring some in.
Legacy needs care too
Rookgaard is legacy. It is where generations of players killed their first rat, got their first scare from a troll and dreamed about the Mainland. It is as much a part of the game’s history as Thais or Carlin.
Legacy doesn’t mean frozen. It means care. And care, here, is something small:
- bring echo raids back to the island, or at least explain why they were removed;
- before removing a mechanic from Rookgaard, ask whether it bothers anyone instead of just switching it off;
- reply, even once, to the thread of players who have been on the island for years.
Nobody on Rookgaard is asking to change the game. They are asking not to lose the little they gained. For a community that has kept Tibia’s front door alive for almost 30 years, it is a very cheap request to grant.

Comments
0